I previously wrote that I was considering a Toyota Prius to replace my Dodge Charger R/T, which has approached its lease mileage limit and sucks down over $500 in gas per month. I was interested in the Prius, even despite its stunted-tortoise looks, until I drove it.
I'm a car guy. I've always had a car with some degree of power and agility. The Prius, however, is the diametric opposite of that: it's ungodly slow and handles like a whale on a skateboard. It does one thing very well: bring the MPGs. Aside from that, I found it to be soulless driving. I could not see myself living with it for six months, let alone a few years.
My quest led me to the 2008 VW 4-door GTI, which I've always admired as a cheap, economical, yet powerful hatchback that has been through its ups and downs since its debut in 1983. Today's version -- the MkV, arguably the best ever -- shares its chassis with the Audi A3, and for the price, I could not find another car that had what the GTI offered. The DSG (direct shift gearbox) transmission -- a six-speed, dual-clutch, semi-manual setup -- was the deal-maker for me, as I found its performance (and lack of normal auto transmission downsides like a torque converter) to be spectacular. I think the DSG defines the platform, frankly.
As for MPGs, if you keep your foot out of the 2.0L turbocharged/intercooled engine, you can see up to 32-34 MPG on the highway. Get into the boost too hard, though, and you'll get around 22-24. So far, I'm getting about 30-31 MPG back and forth from work, and that's on an engine with only ~100 miles on it.
To me, the Prius gives up way too much to deliver its efficiency (and that doesn't even factor in the inevitable hybrid vs. conventional price breakeven calculations). It does one thing very well. However, as a car enthusiast, I'm willing to take less MPGs for the GTI's surprisingly edgy Mr. Hyde capabilities.
So, the decision is made and I've taken delivery of the car. Full review to follow if y'all want it.
Comments [0]