Many people have been asking me for my iPad review, presumably because the glowing, over-the-top hyperbole that the mainstream outlets have gushing out their maws has been (a) read several times over already, or (b) met with some degree of skepticism, and they're now looking for a more real-world review from your average Joe on the street.
So, here goes, in no particular order. I'm going to get a bit of cognitive dissonance out of the way first, so if it seems like I'm harshing on the iPad too much at first, read the whole thing.
(Also, I'm intentionally going to avoid the whole closed v. open debate, brought to a head by
Cory Doctorow's screed, which I found to be quite off base for someone so typically astute. I might tackle that later.)
Let's get back to the title of this post. When I say 'caught between two worlds,' that's the overall feeling I have when using the iPad. Some of this feeling is intentional -- remember Steve Jobs's slide that shows the iPad shoehorned in between the iPhone and laptop? -- and some of it seems the unintended consequence of birthing a device that is simultaneously incredibly fucking good and brand new with no usage baseline whatsoever.
Examples:
I find myself wanting to get my calendar information, which is stored in Google Calendar, into the iPad's Calendar app. But then, why? The browser is fantastic, and its size and resolution encamp it firmly in the company of desktop browsers. So, I fire up Google Calendar in Safari, and there she is, resplendent.
Caught.
I punch in an address in Maps and marvel for longer than I should at the gorgeous display and utterly massive improvement it represents over the iPhone's app of the same name. I want to get some directions out of the app, but then I realize I can only email the link somewhere. I can't print, because there are no print drivers or print subsystem. My mind wants to do what I'd do with a 'main' machine, but I can't because the OS doesn't yet support certain desktop functions. It's a mobile device that makes you want to work on it like a full computer.
Caught.
I took a bunch of campy pictures of my son as he tore through the house at just under Mach 1 to find his Easter eggs, and I want to get them on the iPad quickly and easily for viewing and light editing. As of now -- with no USB ports and no commercially-available camera connection kit -- I can't, so while my mind says Yes, I want to do this work on this iPad because I enjoy it, I can't. I have to use my MacBook Pro.
Caught.
There are other examples, but you get the point.
Read the rest of this post »